Last Updated on March 26, 2023 by mishou
1. I typed:
Tell me what is to write logically and what is needed for logical writing.
To write logically means to present ideas, arguments, and conclusions in a clear and rational way that makes sense to the reader. Logical writing involves organizing your thoughts in a structured and coherent manner that allows your reader to follow your reasoning and understand your perspective.
To write logically, you should consider the following key elements:
Clarity: Make sure your writing is clear, concise, and free from ambiguity. Use precise language and avoid vague or general statements.
Coherence: Ensure that your writing is organized and flows logically from one idea to the next. Use transitions and connective words to link your thoughts together.
Consistency: Maintain consistency in your writing by using the same terminology and concepts throughout. Avoid contradictions or confusing statements.
Evidence: Support your arguments with evidence from reliable sources. Use data, examples, and expert opinions to reinforce your points.
Validity: Ensure that your arguments are valid and supported by sound reasoning. Avoid fallacies or unsupported claims.
Structure: Use a clear and logical structure for your writing, such as an introduction, body, and conclusion. Use headings and subheadings to organize your ideas.
By focusing on these elements, you can write in a way that is logical, persuasive, and easy to understand for your readers.
2. I typed:
Isn’t it essential to properly use the words that stand for logical relation, that is, “but”, “however”, “because”, “therefore” and so on for logical writing?
Yes, using words and phrases that signal logical relationships between ideas is crucial for logical writing. Words such as “but,” “however,” “because,” “therefore,” and “consequently” are examples of transitional words that help to establish the logical connection between ideas in your writing.
Using these words and phrases correctly helps to create coherence and flow in your writing, making it easier for your reader to understand the relationships between your ideas. Additionally, these words and phrases help to highlight the logical structure of your argument and demonstrate the progression of your ideas.
However, it’s important to note that simply using these words and phrases is not enough on its own to make your writing logical. You must also ensure that the ideas and arguments you present are supported by evidence, are valid, and follow a clear and organized structure.
So while using transitional words is an important component of logical writing, it is just one element of a larger set of strategies that help you to write clearly and persuasively.
3. I typed:
I have another opinion. The “evidence” that you mentioned is certainly crucial for writing persuasively but is not necessary for writing logically. For example, “IF A is B and A, therefore, B.” is a logically written sentence. But it need no evidence because it says nothing about the world, as Ludwig Wittgenstein said, or most logicians think. You can say a persuasive essay should be written logically and show evidence enough for persuading readers. However, you should discuss the logical writing and persuasive writing separately.
You make a valid point that evidence may not always be necessary for logical writing. In certain cases, such as in deductive reasoning or mathematical proofs, evidence may not be required as the conclusion can be logically inferred from the premises.
However, in most cases, evidence is necessary to support your arguments and make your writing more convincing. In persuasive writing, evidence is especially important as it helps to establish the credibility of your claims and persuade the reader to accept your point of view.
That being said, I agree with your assertion that logical writing is not necessarily the same as persuasive writing. While logical writing involves presenting ideas in a clear and rational manner, persuasive writing goes a step further by trying to convince the reader to accept a particular point of view. While both styles of writing require logical coherence, persuasive writing places greater emphasis on evidence and persuasive techniques such as emotional appeals and rhetorical devices.
In summary, while evidence may not always be necessary for logical writing, it is an important component of persuasive writing. Logical writing involves presenting ideas in a clear and coherent manner, while persuasive writing seeks to persuade the reader to accept a particular point of view through the use of evidence and persuasive techniques.
4. I typed:
The distinction between logical writing and persuasive writing is crucial for writing a good essay. If you feel your essay is not good, it can be bad for not writing logically or for lacking enough evidence or for both. You should discuss them distinctly.
Yes, I agree that distinguishing between logical writing and persuasive writing is important for writing a good essay. While logical writing involves presenting ideas in a clear and rational manner, persuasive writing involves persuading the reader to accept a particular point of view through the use of evidence and persuasive techniques.
If your essay is not good, it could be due to a lack of logical coherence or a lack of persuasive power. For example, your essay may lack logical coherence if your ideas are not presented in a clear and organized manner, or if you fail to connect your ideas in a way that makes sense to the reader. On the other hand, your essay may lack persuasive power if you fail to provide enough evidence to support your arguments or if you do not use persuasive techniques such as emotional appeals or rhetorical devices.
Therefore, it is important to distinguish between logical writing and persuasive writing, and to ensure that your essay is both logically coherent and persuasive. By doing so, you can create an essay that not only presents your ideas clearly and rationally, but also persuades the reader to accept your point of view.
5. I typed:
You’ve got to the point. We should also pay attention to the practical use of the “logical words” or signals. Let’s think about “because”. It can be used not only logically but also causally. When someone says, “It is warm today because of global warming”, he or she need to show evidence enough for persuading me. But when someone says, “It can be hot today because it is either hot or not on any day”, the statement is logically true but says nothing about the facts, so he or she doesn’t need to show any evidence for persuasion. When you write an essay, you should pay attention to the difference for better writing.
Yes, you make an important distinction between the practical use of logical words or signals such as “because” and their relationship to evidence and persuasion. The word “because” can be used in both a logical sense to establish a causal relationship between two ideas, as well as in a persuasive sense to support an argument with evidence.
For example, in the statement “It is warm today because of global warming,” the word “because” is used to establish a causal relationship between global warming and the current warm temperature. In this case, the speaker would need to provide evidence to support the claim that global warming is causing the current warm temperature in order to persuade the listener.
On the other hand, in the statement “It can be hot today because it is either hot or not on any day,” the word “because” is used in a logical sense to establish a necessary condition for the occurrence of a hot day. In this case, no evidence is necessary to support the claim, as it is logically true based on the definition of a hot day.
When writing an essay, it is important to pay attention to the practical use of logical words and signals and how they relate to evidence and persuasion. By doing so, you can use these words and signals effectively to support your arguments and establish logical coherence in your writing.